NHL GM Wars Game Thread

[Malkamaniac]

Who's bad Shaft?

Or is your superiority in this game only applicable to the eastern conference?

Please ask THG in the dead thread what's up. He seems to have it on lockdown.

[MWB]

Before this vote roles on too quickly, as I fear it will, relantel didn't vote last round. However, when the vote was done he made sure to come on and say he was suspicious of me. Kind of laying the groundwork for the next vote.

[cup keeper]

i forgot about this... am I still alive? Id it worth going through 15 pages?

WC Fire Jose Cuervo

With the playoffs starting next round do we want someone around who hasn't been paying attention?

[PensFanInDC]

EC
1 - TW, (canaan)
1 - MWB, (shaf)

WC
1 - nan, (Troy Loney)
1 - JC, (cup keeper)

5 to fire

[shafnutz05]

If I didn't vote for sdm I would have been guilty for not voting. Since I voted and used logic, I'm also guilty?

When did I say I was "extremely hesitant" to vote for sdm? If it's because I didn't vote for him earlier, then I was extremely hesitant about everyone.

It was the timing of it. You came in as the final, deciding vote. And the stuff with tfrizz, IMO, was a smokescreen put up by you and MWB. I could very well be wrong here....there is only one red left, so the odds aren't exactly with us.

[Troy Loney]

Who's bad Shaft?

Or is your superiority in this game only applicable to the eastern conference?

And to think I joined the Raisin Bran Alliance with you

I'm trying to employ your expertise on a contractual basis for the west....But the Red Wing's organization does not like the "in retrospect" criticism of your post.

[Kicksave]

WC Fire Troy Loney

I'm going back to this. I have a feeling I let a baddie off the hook

[MWB]

Sorry, my mistake above. Relantel did vote for TW last round. He and npv were the two not to vote for sdm.

[npv708]

I think either MWB or relantel is a good direction to go for the EC.

ps. I wasn't around yet for the sdm vote, or else I would've changed, especially since sdm called me out.

you would've changed because sdm called you out?

not because, but as an added reason.

[Kicksave]

color fail.

WC Fire Troy Loney

[canaan]

I think either MWB or relantel is a good direction to go for the EC.

ps. I wasn't around yet for the sdm vote, or else I would've changed, especially since sdm called me out.

you would've changed because sdm called you out?

not because, but as an added reason.

what was the other reason?

[Malkamaniac]

EC Kill TW

Random, no explanation. What's up Canaan?

[Troy Loney]

WC Fire Troy Loney

I'm going back to this. I have a feeling I let a baddie off the hook

Yeah well, i'm starting to think that your bad.

[Kicksave]

WC Fire Troy Loney

I'm going back to this. I have a feeling I let a baddie off the hook

Yeah well, i'm starting to think that your bad.

lol, ok dagny.

[PensFanInDC]

EC
1 - TW, (canaan)
1 - MWB, (shaf)

WC
1 - nan, (Troy Loney)
1 - JC, (cup keeper)
1 - Troy Loney, (Kicksave)

5 to fire

[Troy Loney]

color fail.

WC Fire Troy Loney

[MWB]

If I didn't vote for sdm I would have been guilty for not voting. Since I voted and used logic, I'm also guilty?

When did I say I was "extremely hesitant" to vote for sdm? If it's because I didn't vote for him earlier, then I was extremely hesitant about everyone.

It was the timing of it. You came in as the final, deciding vote. And the stuff with tfrizz, IMO, was a smokescreen put up by you and MWB. I could very well be wrong here....there is only one red left, so the odds aren't exactly with us.

The timing of it was after sdm made his claim on tfrizz. Since he said to wait, I thought it would be prudent to see what he had to say (y'know, in case he had a role). When nothing relevant came out it seemed like a good choice.

And yes, you are wrong here.

[tfrizz]

Here are a couple of observations/theories I made while waiting for day to arrive:

• Twisted Wrister's last post on the board was Sunday night, which makes me 99% sure he's just a villager.
• I don't believe all 3 baddies would jump on the THG bandwagon. This leaves me with canaan, npv708, or the wicked child.
• Eastern Conference >>> Western Conference

EC Fire George McPhee (the wicked child)

He didn't vote on Day 1, and his late vote on sdm - after sdm started panicking - feels a little off.

[shafnutz05]

Sorry, my mistake above. Relantel did vote for TW last round. He and npv were the two not to vote for sdm.

MWB, let me look at this....

Relantel has voted for THG and TW, correct?

I see your point about relantel....but the link between you and SDM is kind of hard to ignore right now.

[Senka]

Im going back to where I was. I had a hunch and didnt follow it and ill be so mad knowing i was THIS close and failed.

WC Fire LITT.

regardless if you voted in red, Im trying to figure this one out...

but on the flipside... JC seems to be safe if he indeed wasnt around. so we'd atleast avoid the vig with him. although we wouldnt help out eliminating the red members. so its kinda like a safe/sorry approach CK. I can see it both ways.

[Troy Loney]

Wait, ignore my face palm on that...i had it highlighted and forgot that i highlighted it, looked at it and saw it was blue and thought you made a double fail.

[canaan]

EC Kill TW

Random, no explanation. What's up Canaan?

completely a hunch. i dont know how i feel about the mwb situation atm and i dont remember anything TW has done this game.

[shafnutz05]

tfrizz, that is a list of 3 top suspects that aren't nearly as high on my radar...

My top two are

1) MWB
2) Relantel

I have been tying MWB and SDM together since last round, but I guess I could be convinced to vote for relantel.

[MWB]

Sorry, my mistake above. Relantel did vote for TW last round. He and npv were the two not to vote for sdm.

MWB, let me look at this....

Relantel has voted for THG and TW, correct?

I see your point about relantel....but the link between you and SDM is kind of hard to ignore right now.

What link are you talking about? You created this link in your mind.

[npv708]

EC HIRE MWB
EC FIRE SDM

I still really like my line of thinking on MWB, but I am willing to go for SDM and see where this goes as well. Suddenly SDM is a lot more active immediately after he is called out.

9:20 break. so i will disappear in 5 minutes at 9:40 until lunch

and then it will be OMG SDM hasn't posted

I get it its day 2 so the village has to go on what little they have and if this is it okay,, but pay attention that canaan voted for me first both days. thats all i am sayin

To me, this seemed suspicious. He had 2 votes on him at this point and came out like that.