shafnutz05 wrote:And to add to the note about pfidc, that is exactly the kind of "on the fence" comments that are popular with reds because they are noncommittal to either side. And I really don't understand his forceful push at implicating THG.
I don't know about PFIDC, but thg's lack of, not only reading comprehension, but reading AT ALL is incredibly disturbing. Not to mention annoying, useless, and possibly detrimental to the village.
The evidence is all right here. The answers to his questions are right in front of his face, yet he refuses to read?
That's more than enough to convince me he needs to go. All he's done is talk smack to wally and try to get an outed green RPer killed.
Well, I mean, I really don't like to be a downer, but there really are a ton of questions regarding why you lived, and outside of the "Oh I'm the Joat theory" nothing really is adding up.
I don't see why you can't say what kind of "power" you have.
As a red joat, could she maybe have protected herself from her own group to stage it.
Or do the bad guys maybe have an option that they could do that...to try and build trust with the village. I mean, that's not outside of the LOST universe, for sure.
Honestly, between THG and Dagny, this is just terrible for the sake of confusion. This is the kind of stuff the baddies love because it does nothing but enable them to dig further into the village.
Malkamaniac wrote:Honestly, between THG and Dagny, this is just terrible for the sake of confusion. This is the kind of stuff the baddies love because it does nothing but enable them to dig further into the village.
Malkamaniac wrote:Honestly, between THG and Dagny, this is just terrible for the sake of confusion. This is the kind of stuff the baddies love because it does nothing but enable them to dig further into the village.
You're not only pointing that out, but adding to it.
Malkamaniac wrote:Honestly, between THG and Dagny, this is just terrible for the sake of confusion. This is the kind of stuff the baddies love because it does nothing but enable them to dig further into the village.
You're not only pointing that out, but adding to it.
Because I'm asking that we decide this now instead of continuing on with the constant crap that were going to deal with for the next 3 day phases?
As a red joat, could she maybe have protected herself from her own group to stage it.
I see this as a possibility. And Dagny as one of the few people to try it.
She knew she was in trouble when she got captured day 1 and came up with this to if nothing else throw the village into disarray, but that is still pretty far fetched
not enough for me to cast a vote
count2infinity wrote:i say we kill a quiet player today (hope to get lucky and hit a baddie) and just see what happens tonight, maybe it could give us some answers.
I say we don't. Not going after dagny is not sensible, IMO. I apologize if that sounds nasty, but I don't get why we would be leaving this thing around.
shafnutz05 wrote:And to add to the note about pfidc, that is exactly the kind of "on the fence" comments that are popular with reds because they are noncommittal to either side. And I really don't understand his forceful push at implicating THG.
I don't know about PFIDC, but thg's lack of, not only reading comprehension, but reading AT ALL is incredibly disturbing. Not to mention annoying, useless, and possibly detrimental to the village.
The evidence is all right here. The answers to his questions are right in front of his face, yet he refuses to read?
That's more than enough to convince me he needs to go. All he's done is talk smack to wally and try to get an outed green RPer killed.
Well, I mean, I really don't like to be a downer, but there really are a ton of questions regarding why you lived, and outside of the "Oh I'm the Joat theory" nothing really is adding up.
I don't see why you can't say what kind of "power" you have.
I CAN say, and I've said that multiple times. I can also use it to prove my role, but I'm waiting for the village to weigh in, as I've said multiple times. (why do i have to keep repeating myself when the posts are all right there?)
I was just trying not to reveal everything to the baddies, but if you guys are gonna kill me anyway, I might as well reveal it. You guys always forget SEnka's words about giving too much away, or prodding a RPer into giving too much away because you just HAVE to know.
I've asked you guys if you want me to tell you, but I need more than a couple of people saying "yeah, tell us your power". Of course the bad guys are gonna want me to reveal it.
I CAN say, and I've said that multiple times. I can also use it to prove my role, but I'm waiting for the village to weigh in, as I've said multiple times. (why do i have to keep repeating myself when the posts are all right there?)
I was just trying not to reveal everything to the baddies, but if you guys are gonna kill me anyway, I might as well reveal it. You guys always forget SEnka's words about giving too much away, or prodding a RPer into giving too much away because you just HAVE to know.
I've asked you guys if you want me to tell you, but I need more than a couple of people saying "yeah, tell us your power". Of course the bad guys are gonna want me to reveal it.
Fair enough I guess. I'm not voting for you at this moment, because while I feel that it's suspicious, leaving you alive for the time being answers more questions than you being dead, because afterall, if you're "green," I don't see you making it out of the night phases since you've admitting you can do more than one thing harmful to the baddies.
I say we got for cupkeeper. he's bad like 90% of the time.
Other than that, I can get on board with a dagny vote. regardless of whether she's good or bad, she's done nothing but confuse you people up to this point. Kill her or don't, we don't need to spend the entire time limit trying to figure out if we should kill her
As much as I want to vote for dagny again, this reminds me of the bhaw situation in the WCW warz, with demanding all questions be answered immediately.
What I'm asking for is to cut the crap. The only way we can end this is to:
a) trust dagny, and kill thg
b) kill Dagny, and trust THG for once
c) kill a random and hope for more answers.
i don't believe dagny's story at all for one reason....she used the "mayor" role to explain surviving the lynch.
1. that role was used only once or twice in these games and never stuck.
2. it wouldn't be called "mayor", if it were some power for this game i bet it would have some lost connotation to the role or power title.
