Which posting, specifically?redwill wrote:arrest dodint
He just seems a bit odd in his posting. Of course, I thought last game, too, and was wrong.
Or do you mean all of them?
Which posting, specifically?redwill wrote:arrest dodint
He just seems a bit odd in his posting. Of course, I thought last game, too, and was wrong.
Yeah, all of them I guess.dodint wrote:Which posting, specifically?
Or do you mean all of them?
I don't think it's of the utmost importance or I would've voted for him. Like I said before, even if he's the angel (which we don't know) he can only protect himself so he's basically a citizen with immunity. He doesn't hurt us by staying alive, but he's not helping and has some ambiguity surrounding him with the claim. If he claimed to be a valuable RP like the vig or seer I wouldn't vote for him at all, but then he'd be able to provide something, too.MWB wrote:Again, I don't get this thinking. Why is it so important that we get rid of mr.dodint wrote:I think MR25 is a lame duck but I don't think I could get any vote support so I'm not bothering. If a run goes that way I'll jump in a heartbeat, but doing the stalemate thing all day for him *again* seems wasteful.
Having someone we know isn't red has value. More value than a player who kills blues.dodint wrote:I don't think it's of the utmost importance or I would've voted for him. Like I said before, even if he's the angel (which we don't know) he can only protect himself so he's basically a citizen with immunity. He doesn't hurt us by staying alive, but he's not helping and has some ambiguity surrounding him with the claim. If he claimed to be a valuable RP like the vig or seer I wouldn't vote for him at all, but then he'd be able to provide something, too.MWB wrote:Again, I don't get this thinking. Why is it so important that we get rid of mr.dodint wrote:I think MR25 is a lame duck but I don't think I could get any vote support so I'm not bothering. If a run goes that way I'll jump in a heartbeat, but doing the stalemate thing all day for him *again* seems wasteful.
Having anybody we know who isn't red is valuable (vig, seer, angel, or porcupine). The problem is that we just take his word for it when other roles can provide proof.MWB wrote:Having someone we know isn't red has value. More value than a player who kills blues.dodint wrote:I don't think it's of the utmost importance or I would've voted for him. Like I said before, even if he's the angel (which we don't know) he can only protect himself so he's basically a citizen with immunity. He doesn't hurt us by staying alive, but he's not helping and has some ambiguity surrounding him with the claim. If he claimed to be a valuable RP like the vig or seer I wouldn't vote for him at all, but then he'd be able to provide something, too.MWB wrote:Again, I don't get this thinking. Why is it so important that we get rid of mr.dodint wrote:I think MR25 is a lame duck but I don't think I could get any vote support so I'm not bothering. If a run goes that way I'll jump in a heartbeat, but doing the stalemate thing all day for him *again* seems wasteful.
columbia wrote:We (the village) are really kicking some ass in this game. :face:
Arrest columbia.columbia wrote:I'm putting my vote back on him...
arrest MR25
MWB wrote:columbia wrote:We (the village) are really kicking some ass in this game.Arrest columbia.columbia wrote:I'm putting my vote back on him...
arrest MR25
Color
I don't get the insistence on voting for mr. And the, oh, this village sucks thing is sometimes a tell. Not sure where else to go right now.
Ok, this really muddies things up.CBear3 wrote:Having anybody we know who isn't red is valuable (vig, seer, angel, or porcupine). The problem is that we just take his word for it when other roles can provide proof.MWB wrote:Having someone we know isn't red has value. More value than a player who kills blues.dodint wrote:I don't think it's of the utmost importance or I would've voted for him. Like I said before, even if he's the angel (which we don't know) he can only protect himself so he's basically a citizen with immunity. He doesn't hurt us by staying alive, but he's not helping and has some ambiguity surrounding him with the claim. If he claimed to be a valuable RP like the vig or seer I wouldn't vote for him at all, but then he'd be able to provide something, too.MWB wrote:Again, I don't get this thinking. Why is it so important that we get rid of mr.dodint wrote:I think MR25 is a lame duck but I don't think I could get any vote support so I'm not bothering. If a run goes that way I'll jump in a heartbeat, but doing the stalemate thing all day for him *again* seems wasteful.
*If* I was the real angel, I wouldn't come forward until we bag a red (because the only harm Mr25 can do right now is muddy the waters a bit). As our numbers decrease, his influence increases and that's when I'd unmask myself. Like I said, tomorrow would probably be my day based on numbers; which is why I'll still be suspicious until that day ends.
If you put enough heat on a red masquerading as an angel, they might crack.MWB wrote: I don't get the insistence on voting for mr. And the, oh, this village sucks thing is sometimes a tell. Not sure where else to go right now.
Then I guess I'd make a crap angel, and we're lucky I'm not one in this game.MWB wrote:Ok, this really muddies things up.CBear3 wrote:
Having anybody we know who isn't red is valuable (vig, seer, angel, or porcupine). The problem is that we just take his word for it when other roles can provide proof.
*If* I was the real angel, I wouldn't come forward until we bag a red (because the only harm Mr25 can do right now is muddy the waters a bit). As our numbers decrease, his influence increases and that's when I'd unmask myself. Like I said, tomorrow would probably be my day based on numbers; which is why I'll still be suspicious until that day ends.
It muddies things because I think you make a fair point, but it also seems like you're claiming to be the angel without actually doing it.CBear3 wrote:Then I guess I'd make a crap angel, and we're lucky I'm not one in this game.MWB wrote:Ok, this really muddies things up.CBear3 wrote:
Having anybody we know who isn't red is valuable (vig, seer, angel, or porcupine). The problem is that we just take his word for it when other roles can provide proof.
*If* I was the real angel, I wouldn't come forward until we bag a red (because the only harm Mr25 can do right now is muddy the waters a bit). As our numbers decrease, his influence increases and that's when I'd unmask myself. Like I said, tomorrow would probably be my day based on numbers; which is why I'll still be suspicious until that day ends.
I'll change my vote if the situation warrants it....besides, no one else is going to vote for him today, so it doesn't really matter.MWB wrote:Scrutinized, yes. Voted out, no. And if waiting for tomorrow is ok, why vote for him?
I mean, I just woke up...CBear3 wrote:Argh, I didn't edit, I quoted I thought. I added:
Note, two of those have already been vocal today & MR25 has now joined us, all without adding a whole lot of positive direction towards a vote, only defenses.
I'm rarely absent on purpose, but I like the fact that people always claim that I'm hard to read. It's the best way to play the game, IMO.MRandall25 wrote:I never know what to think with redwill lately in these games. He's sort of becoming a rel, who posts just enough to make it look like he's contributing, but is absent enough (probably for reasons outside of the board) that you can't get a good read on him.
#humblebragMRandall25 wrote:I mean, I just woke up...CBear3 wrote:Argh, I didn't edit, I quoted I thought. I added:
Note, two of those have already been vocal today & MR25 has now joined us, all without adding a whole lot of positive direction towards a vote, only defenses.
Right now, I think dodint or redwill is our best look.
I figured you were just expressing some glands.redwill wrote:I'm rarely absent on purpose, but I like the fact that people always claim that I'm hard to read. It's the best way to play the game, IMO.MRandall25 wrote:I never know what to think with redwill lately in these games. He's sort of becoming a rel, who posts just enough to make it look like he's contributing, but is absent enough (probably for reasons outside of the board) that you can't get a good read on him.
Haha. I let the vets do that. They're the ones with the scrubs.columbia wrote:I figured you were just expressing some glands.