**Official MAFIA Gameplay thread**

[LeopardLetang]

Then I'm going with a pick of someone I haven't seen post in here yet:

lynch SDM5055

I recommend not doing this....
cant really defend much on the first night and nobody has much to go on so I ask that people go on my word to not lynch me

it would be better for the town if you didn't

[jwienand]

I'll go with Juice too. He always says there's a quie wolf/mafia.

Arrest Juice

[MWB]

I will prob have to bust this open once day comes around to keep living in a mad mad world

I'm not positive, but I think it was this line. I hadn't caught onto it at the time.

[Senka]

Lets pull it out of our butts.

[IrishEyes]

Then I'm going with a pick of someone I haven't seen post in here yet:

lynch SDM5055

I recommend not doing this....
cant really defend much on the first night and nobody has much to go on so I ask that people go on my word to not lynch me

it would be better for the town if you didn't

And that immediately made me suspicious, because it's an easy ploy for the mafia to use. It worked for him, only because people were targeting players who weren't participating.

[beerman]

I will prob have to bust this open once day comes around to keep living in a mad mad world

I'm not positive, but I think it was this line. I hadn't caught onto it at the time.

see LL's post above, then he was talking about how 2 role players were known and that one was from posts prior to Dagny being saved which was referencing what LL quoted.

Back to beerland.

[Senka]

Im not all about juice though... like just because hes not here... so im not voting that way. i have class till 5 anyways, so if its not decided by then maybe ill change my mind up but again... not a fan.

[Idoit40fans]

I have no idea how any of that outed sdm, looks like the same defense that people have used throughout all of these games to me. Whatever, I guess enough people saw something different that was significant though.

[Idoit40fans]

Juice himself said that there is always a quiet "bad guy", and its impossible to gauge people that aren't participating much(even if we are wrong on how we read them most of the time anyway). Win-win.

[jwienand]

I think it was NAN saying 2 were known??? Not sure but after I read that I looked back through all the posts and just figured that's what he meant. 1 thing, When they tried to kill Dags, TW wrote her name in blue. This definately means she is a villager, but maybe the doctor just got lucky??? I'm pretty sure we all think Dags is the doc because of this but who knows maybe the Doctor is still unknown.

[Senka]

I think it was NAN saying 2 were known??? Not sure but after I read that I looked back through all the posts and just figured that's what he meant. 1 thing, When they tried to kill Dags, TW wrote her name in blue. This definately means she is a villager, but maybe the doctor just got lucky??? I'm pretty sure we all think Dags is the doc because of this but who knows maybe the Doctor is still unknown.

yeah it helped me out big time. i know in WW, juice wrote ":there was no action tonight:" just saying that that person has been saved... not giving that info to the village... but hey it helped me figure out who was who..

so be it. ugh. as for the bad boy comment, that was interesting...

[Senka]

Warrents..

Juice - 4

Good luck. back at 5pm.

[Senka]

or warrants.

[JoseCuervo]

i was totally going to do that too idiot, lol!

arrest juice

[MWB]

arrest juice

[Azkar]

I'm not sold on arresting juice just to arrest someone, there has been someone that has been very suspicious to me, however.


arrest troy

[Troy Loney]

I'm not sold on arresting juice just to arrest someone, there has been someone that has been very suspicious to me, however.


arrest troy

meh...not a bad thing...i don't bring much to the table...it wouldn't hurt anything to lynch me.

[Juice]

yeah good thinking guys and girls
i always have said theres a quiet bad guy
so why would i be quiet if i was a bad guy?
such first level thinking....
i've actually been around, just not posting in the thread.
let me read over the thread and see if i can't do some fingering out

[Juice]

k well i didn't have to do much reading to make me think that JoseCuervo is a mobster...
i don't feel like cutting and pasting in the posts why, just trust me when i say that he has been acting too "town first"
alot of times people that aren't in the general population overact like they are
go back and read some of his posts in the thread
arrest JoseCuervo

[wallflower]

I have no idea how any of that outed sdm, looks like the same defense that people have used throughout all of these games to me. Whatever, I guess enough people saw something different that was significant though.

It's funny how people interpret things differently. I immediately thought after sdm made that post that either he really was a "good guy" role player (and, subsequently didn't use a lot of common sense in saying that) or he was a mafioso trying to deflect. If the mafia hadn't taken him out, I was going to vote to arrest him next.

So yeah. I kind of suck at this game.

[Idoit40fans]

yeah good thinking guys and girls
i always have said theres a quiet bad guy
so why would i be quiet if i was a bad guy?
such first level thinking....
i've actually been around, just not posting in the thread.
let me read over the thread and see if i can't do some fingering out

actually I took it to mean that there is always someone thats barely participating that is a wolf. Regardless, i'm not changing.

[Idoit40fans]

I should probably amend that, if we get through to really late tonight and one vote is needed to move on, I might consider it, but I have no intention of changing at this point.

Aside from that, the condescending nature of that response makes me want to take you down either way.

[Juice]

pls everyone go back to the end of page 12 and read my two posts... i don't want them to get lost in the shuffle

[Juice]

Aside from that, the condescending nature of that response makes me want to take you down either way.

i just didn't think you thought it through all the way before you voted me

[Twisted Wrister]

Warrant count-
Juice- 6 (Idoit, Troy, IE, Jwe, Jose, MWB)

Troy- 1 (Azkar)

Jose- 1 (Juice)

Need 9 to lynch