History Mafia -- GAME THREAD

[slappybrown]

lynch slappy

I don't like that massive argument that he created for TWC.

Hey, I was wrong, but I posted what I found and many of you (including you) found it persuasive.

And please go back and look at my voting history if you think I'm bad. Its pretty obvious I am a townie.

[relantel]

Wow, you guys sure finished IE off fast this AM, and the RPs made fast work, that by the time I get on it's the next day already.

Zaro and cupkeeper were next on bhaw's list. I still think zaro is good, so I'll lynch cupkeeper.

[beerman]

Vote Count:

cupkeeper - 2 - npv, relantel
npv - 1 - zaro
slappy - 1 - Troy

[PensFanInDC]

I want to wait and heat what bhaw has to say. But he did tell us to look at his suspicions.

I'll still wait to hear from him.

[Troy Loney]

lynch slappy

I don't like that massive argument that he created for TWC.

Hey, I was wrong, but I posted what I found and many of you (including you) found it persuasive.

And please go back and look at my voting history if you think I'm bad. Its pretty obvious I am a townie.

I said i liked the cupkeeper argument...i went with twc because i was sick of trying to explain why i considered him a bad vote....there were too many voices going in the other direction and i dont think anyone really trusts me anyway.

[count2infinity]

i don't know why zaro is rubbing me the wrong way, but every time he says something red flags go up. then i remember that he was really pushing for redwill before bhaw came out as the cop and i convince myself that he's not bad.

[Troy Loney]

i don't know why zaro is rubbing me the wrong way, but every time he says something red flags go up. then i remember that he was really pushing for redwill before bhaw came out as the cop and i convince myself that he's not bad.

I'm not basing anything on that.....this game is obviously just flowing through bhaw (see pfidc's post)....if he's good than the mafia is using his suspicion's on innocents to try and push those lynches, and also jumping on the mafia votes to try and clear themselves.

If bhaw is bad than they are all just pretending to be reluctant to follow him.

[Zarovich]

crayz death showing him being blue makes me think cupkeeper is bad per what I was sayoing about the early bhaw votes. I also still think npv is bad and trying to lynch a fellow red and then get me out while earning the trust of the village.

[PensFanInDC]

bhaw, bhaw! Where for art though bhaw!?

[PensFanInDC]

though = thou

[PensFanInDC]

I'm going to throw this out before I go to bed too...

Maybe the reason I'm still around is because I nailed a bunch of the mafia and it seems like as long as I'm here, either I'm suspect or whoever I vote for is suspect. If I die, I show up as being the cop, and all the mafia start getting voted out if you follow my hunches (which typically happens in this scenario).

I'm out for the rest of the night and get up later than you all again.

IE is definitely bad. Don't over think it. The simplest explanation is usually the best: bhaw is good like he says he is. Lots of people suspected IE, and rightfully so... she is bad.

After that, I think Zaro has to be suspect. Cup keeper is suspect.

Im going off of this.

Lynch cupkeeper

[cup keeper]

Food for thought before you finish lynching another blue player.

Bhaw hasn't been killed by the mafia because they can still cast doubt on his cop claim and he is barking up the wrong tree with his "suspects" list.

[Corvidae]

AGAIN... LYNCH ZARO!

[Troy Loney]

unlynch slappy

lynch zaro

I don't want to vote with the people that are voting cupkeeper....i just can't understand why the mafia hasn't killed him yet.

[count2infinity]

the only reason i don't like the zaro vote is he was on redwill long before bhaw came out as the cop. doesn't make sense to me.

[Corvidae]

the only reason i don't like the zaro vote is he was on redwill long before bhaw came out as the cop. doesn't make sense to me.

But there was little pressure on Red at the time.

[cup keeper]

I'm off to work. Hopefully I'm still alive when I get home.

lynch npv for eveything I lined out earlier.

[Zarovich]

the only reason i don't like the zaro vote is he was on redwill long before bhaw came out as the cop. doesn't make sense to me.

But there was little pressure on Red at the time.

He had no pressure on himself and nothing on me then why would I come out and go after him if we are both red? Seriously.

[Corvidae]

the only reason i don't like the zaro vote is he was on redwill long before bhaw came out as the cop. doesn't make sense to me.

But there was little pressure on Red at the time.

He had no pressure on himself and nothing on me then why would I come out and go after him if we are both red? Seriously.

Because it was obvious he wasn't going to be killed at the time. IE also voted for Red.

[Troy Loney]

the only reason i don't like the zaro vote is he was on redwill long before bhaw came out as the cop. doesn't make sense to me.

But there was little pressure on Red at the time.

He had no pressure on himself and nothing on me then why would I come out and go after him if we are both red? Seriously.

So you can say this right now?

What made you suspicious of him, why did you go after him? How did you know he was bad?

[relantel]

the only reason i don't like the zaro vote is he was on redwill long before bhaw came out as the cop. doesn't make sense to me.

But there was little pressure on Red at the time.

He had no pressure on himself and nothing on me then why would I come out and go after him if we are both red? Seriously.

There was no pressure on bhaw when he outed himself either.

[PensFanInDC]

Hmmmm....this is interesting...

me iz headn 2 teh penz gam....laterz yinz...

writeup coming

[npv708]

How many mafia members do I have to vote for before I am cleared to some degree?

count it...I voted for NAN multiple times before he came out...
count it...I was one of the first to argue for redwill...i wasn't around for the kill vote, but I voted for him twice earlier
count it...I voted for Irisheyes...

yet there are as many votes for me as there are for someone who only voted for NAN out of those three and that was after he came out...how does this not make sense to anyone else?

Maybe this will clear it up:
Me = 3 mafia votes (NAN, redwill, IE)
cupkeeper = 1 mafia votes (nan after he came out)

thinking about the above who is more suspicious???

[npv708]

the only reason i don't like the zaro vote is he was on redwill long before bhaw came out as the cop. doesn't make sense to me.

so shouldn't a cup keeper vote make sense since he was strongly against a redwill vote?

[Troy Loney]

How many mafia members do I have to vote for before I am cleared to some degree?

count it...I voted for NAN multiple times before he came out...
count it...I was one of the first to argue for redwill...i wasn't around for the kill vote, but I voted for him twice earlier
count it...I voted for Irisheyes...

yet there are as many votes for me as there are for someone who only voted for NAN out of those three and that was after he came out...how does this not make sense to anyone else?

Maybe this will clear it up:
Me = 3 mafia votes (NAN, redwill, IE)
cupkeeper = 1 mafia votes (nan after he came out)

thinking about the above who is more suspicious???

mafia are the only people who know the other mafia