History Mafia -- GAME THREAD

[mac5155]

10 left so yes 6 to lynch

[bhaw]

I was obviously blocked.

[PensFanInDC]

I was obviously blocked.

Well that sucks. I was hoping to use your info to formulate my vote. What say you then bhaw?

[crayz]

wtffff

[Zarovich]

lynch npv

I'll beat this drum some more.

[bhaw]

You guys know my suspicions. I'll abstain from voting for now (have to run out) so you can formulate your own ideas.

[mac5155]

Message from the dead

DO NOT TRUST BHAW! SEE THROUGH WHAT HE IS DOING!

[PensFanInDC]

Message from the dead

DO NOT TRUST BHAW! SEE THROUGH WHAT HE IS DOING!

[count2infinity]

bhaw, what is this magical mystical power that you've now got? or is it something the mafia should not know about?

[cup keeper]

bhaw, what is this magical mystical power that you've now got? or is it something the mafia should not know about?

This strikes me as one of those fishing for information posts that mafia members make.

Sorry bhaw for not trusting you as the cop and not being converted.

[npv708]

Cupkeeper is a mafia member.

NAN = Mafia - cup keeper only voted after he came out, defended him.
redwill = Mafia - cup keeper never voted for him, fought village against going for him
Irisheyes = Mafia - cup keeper never voted for her

lynch cup keeper

[count2infinity]

bhaw, what is this magical mystical power that you've now got? or is it something the mafia should not know about?

This strikes me as one of those fishing for information posts that mafia members make.

Sorry bhaw for not trusting you as the cop and not being converted.

well here's what i'm trying to figure out... the mafia SHOULD have taken out bhaw last night. he can check someone tonight because he was blocked last night. wouldn't it make sense to kill the last town RP??? also, why would they kill crayz? to my knowledge he hasn't said anything of importance that would cause him to be a threat to the mafia. what if he was killed to further validify bhaw's story? why would they kill crayz? did the mafia know that bhaw couldn't be killed?

[cup keeper]

Cupkeeper is a mafia member.

NAN = Mafia - cup keeper only voted after he came out, defended him.
redwill = Mafia - cup keeper never voted for him, fought village against going for him
Irisheyes = Mafia - cup keeper never voted for her

lynch cup keeper

As bad as all that looks, I'm not a mafia member. Think about it like this. I could've played this game the same way I've always have and flew under the radar. Why would I be so obvious in defending mafia members if I was a part of it? That's just suicide.

[Troy Loney]

well here's what i'm trying to figure out... the mafia SHOULD have taken out bhaw last night. he can check someone tonight because he was blocked last night. wouldn't it make sense to kill the last town RP??? also, why would they kill crayz? to my knowledge he hasn't said anything of importance that would cause him to be a threat to the mafia. what if he was killed to further validify bhaw's story? why would they kill crayz? did the mafia know that bhaw couldn't be killed?

there is one good role player left....if said person is not bhaw than that person needs to come out.

you shouldn't stay hidden anymore, we need to know if bhaw is trustworthy because his role doesnt make any sense....the only thing i can figure is that he can see somebody one night and protect himself the other....but that doesnt explain why the mafia hasn't tried to kill him...unless, the only other thing i can think of is if he has some ability to set someone else up, where if the mafia tried to kill him they die instead...thats all i can figure out.

the first scenario kind of makes sense, but that doesnt explain why the mafia hasn't even tried to get him...and the second scenario is unlikely because i just made up that ability.

So all i'm saying is....your a green role player, and your not bhaw let us know....

[count2infinity]

well i'm not green, or i'd come out... of the closet

[beerman]

To fix mac's writeup:

The mafia killed crayz. Crayz was a regular townie

Still alive:
1. count2infinity - Benedict Arnold
2. slappybrown - Helen Herron Taft
3. npv708 - Aaron Burr
5. Troy Loney - JP Morgan
7. relantel - John Adams
10. Zarovich - Ben Franklin
15. Corvidae - Richard Nixon
19. bhaw - Jesse James
20. cupkeeper - Robert Morris
22. PensFanInDC - George Patton




There are now:
3 Mafia Members
1 Town RP
6 Townies

In the encyclopedia with two dates:
canaan - George Washington Carver - TOWN DEUPTY killed by the Mafia on Night 1.
thehockeyguru - Ferdinand Magellan - regular Townie lynched on his boat on day 1.
Dagny – Pocahontas – Mason killed by the Mafia on Night 2
Malkamaniac – Abe Lincoln - Regular Townie killed by the Assassin on Night 2
sdm5055 - Franklin D Roosevelt - Mason lyched by the Townies on Day 2
jaysmiter - Joseph Stalin -TOWN DOCTOR bound and killed by the Mafia on night 3
newarenanow - John Hancock - MAFIA COP lynched by the village on day 3
Hockeynut! - Sitting Bull shot by the assassin
MWB - Robert E. Lee killed by the town on day 4
Kicksave - Andrew Carnegie killed by da (3-6) MAFIA MAFIA
Azkar - Betsy Ross stabbed and run up the flag pole by the town on day 5
LetangIsTheTruth - Jonas Salk killed by the Mafia.
tfrizz - Al Capone last MASON killed by the assassin
redwill - Emperor Pedro II of Brazil - regular mafia, lynched by the village on day 6
Senka - Joseph Schantz killed by da mafia on night 7
The Wicked Child - George Washington beheaded by the Townies on Day 7
Twisted Wrister - John F. Kennedy - TOWN ASSASSIN killed by the mafia on night 8
IrishEyes - Calamity Jane - Mafia Deputy killed by the townies on Day 8
crayz - Henry Ford - Regular Townie, killed by the Mafia on Night 9


6 to Lynch!!

[beerman]

Vote Count:

cupkeeper - 1 - npv

[count2infinity]

you missed zaro's vote for npv, beerman

[beerman]

Vote Count:

npv - 1 - zaro
cupkeeper - 1 - npv

thanks c2i

[cup keeper]

Going back to npv's post about me, there are a few inaccuracies in there.

First off I voted for nan before he posted that he was a bad guy that couldn't play anymore. I voted for him after bhaw pointed out the post about nan listening to the dead voices which is counter to nan's normal style.

My defense of redwill was because the only reason we were talking about him was because of the dead voices. I would've defended anyone that was brought up by the dead people. I did vote for redwill just to get the dead oices question answered. Go back and look.

As for IE, I brought her name up at the end of the last day phase for her refusal to participate. If I wasn't stuck on the fact that I had problems with what bhaw was telling us I would've voted for her too.

If you're gonna lynch, you'll be disappointed that I'm blue and haven't played this very well.

[Troy Loney]

lynch slappy

I don't like that massive argument that he created for TWC.

[npv708]

on a side note: I'm not listening to the dead right now and here's why:

There are reds who are dead. We don't know who the message is coming from. It could be from NAN, redwill, or IE. The redwill message came when only green/blue was dead.

I don't understand why people aren't voting for cupkeeper....

Here is how his game has gone so far:

defend NAN, nan comes out, first vote for NAN...redwill message from dead, fights village against vote for redwill, doesn't vote for redwill, redwill = mafia #2....bhaw claims IE is red, everybody who votes except for Zaro/Cupkeeper vote for IE, IE is red.

cupkeeper only has voted once the entire game for a mafia member. Never in the game at any point outside of after NAN outed himself has cupkeeper placed a vote for NAN, redwill, or IE and has defended him. Either cupkeeper is doing his best THG impression or he is mafia. cupkeeper is not THG, he has to be a mafia member and I'm willing to bet Zarovich is another.

we really need to go after cupkeeper this time.

[npv708]

Going back to npv's post about me, there are a few inaccuracies in there.

First off I voted for nan before he posted that he was a bad guy that couldn't play anymore. I voted for him after bhaw pointed out the post about nan listening to the dead voices which is counter to nan's normal style.

crayz's research showed otherwise...

[beerman]

Vote Count:

npv - 1 - zaro
cupkeeper - 1 - npv
slappy - 1 - Troy

[npv708]

...and now crayz is dead