The Dark Knight Game Thread

[columbia]

lynch mr25

[MWB]

late to the party.... not unsurprising I guess. Rough day.

Easy choice is to string up mrandall. I would have said whilst catching up that canaan was taking off too easily but he claimed before I could post.

It took off easily for a reason.

[slappybrown]

save canaan

I'm voting THG for making conversation for pulling out two greens instead of going bandwagon.

Thank you. Day ones should be straightforward bandwagons. THG jackwagons every game he plays in.

[canaan]

So you got a pm back saying that mrandall isn't town, and instead of holding onto that info to determine if he's red or green, you went for a kill? Seems odd.
I don't really by mrandall's claim either though.

this is why nan's opinion to let him live isnt a terrible idea. if there is a vig, which there has been for most games, randall will die tonight. i just wanted it to be known that he is not town. the pm did NOT list him as red, though. if for some reason there isnt a vig or doesnt have the ability to kill tonight, then here we are tomorrow with doubts about my role because of this.

im just thinking out loud.

[PensHckyFan79]

Vote Count:

THG - 1 - Mrandall25
SDD - 2 - Slappy, Crankshaft
Canaan - 1 - CBear3
Shaf - 1 - Willie Kool
WK - 1 - Shaf
NAN - 1 - THG
MRandall25 - 1 - Canaan, rel, kaizer

[slappybrown]

I am waiting to hear what he has to say, if only because dis gun b gud

[canaan]

So you got a pm back saying that mrandall isn't town, and instead of holding onto that info to determine if he's red or green, you went for a kill? Seems odd.
I don't really by mrandall's claim either though.

this is why nan's opinion to let him live isnt a terrible idea. if there is a vig, which there has been for most games, randall will die tonight. i just wanted it to be known that he is not town. the pm did NOT list him as red, though. if for some reason there isnt a vig or doesnt have the ability to kill tonight, then here we are tomorrow with doubts about my role because of this.

im just thinking out loud.

to clarify, there was no colorization to mrandall. also, there was no colorization to my pm as well, so im assuming PB just isnt using them and mrandall is RED.

[columbia]

Vote Count:

THG - 1 - Mrandall25
SDD - 2 - Slappy, Crankshaft
Canaan - 1 - CBear3
Shaf - 1 - Willie Kool
WK - 1 - Shaf
NAN - 1 - THG
MRandall25 - 1 - Canaan, rel, kaizer

I also voted for MRandall25.

Two distinct role claims in one day phase....and this early in the game.
Yoiks!

[MWB]

So you got a pm back saying that mrandall isn't town, and instead of holding onto that info to determine if he's red or green, you went for a kill? Seems odd.
I don't really by mrandall's claim either though.

this is why nan's opinion to let him live isnt a terrible idea. if there is a vig, which there has been for most games, randall will die tonight. i just wanted it to be known that he is not town. the pm did NOT list him as red, though. if for some reason there isnt a vig or doesnt have the ability to kill tonight, then here we are tomorrow with doubts about my role because of this.

im just thinking out loud.

Maybe you should think in your head before putting up a possible green player in a random list to off him.

[canaan]

late to the party.... not unsurprising I guess. Rough day.

Easy choice is to string up mrandall. I would have said whilst catching up that canaan was taking off too easily but he claimed before I could post.

It took off easily for a reason.

i can agree to that. day 1, posting irregularly, what you've mentioned.

[Sam's Drunk Dog]

I have a theory that I will share once mrandall explains himself.

[newarenanow]

I'm also willing to look and vote for rel.

To me, there are 3 people that I'm comfortable are blue.

[canaan]

So you got a pm back saying that mrandall isn't town, and instead of holding onto that info to determine if he's red or green, you went for a kill? Seems odd.
I don't really by mrandall's claim either though.

this is why nan's opinion to let him live isnt a terrible idea. if there is a vig, which there has been for most games, randall will die tonight. i just wanted it to be known that he is not town. the pm did NOT list him as red, though. if for some reason there isnt a vig or doesnt have the ability to kill tonight, then here we are tomorrow with doubts about my role because of this.

im just thinking out loud.

Maybe you should think in your head before putting up a possible green player in a random list to off him.

i think its a risk im willing to take

[PensHckyFan79]

Vote Count:

THG - 1 - Mrandall25
SDD - 2 - Slappy, Crankshaft
Canaan - 1 - CBear3
Shaf - 1 - Willie Kool
WK - 1 - Shaf
NAN - 1 - THG
MRandall25 - 4 - Canaan, rel, kaizer, columbia

* sorry I missed your vote, there was a lot going on while I was trying to catch up from Canaan's RP claim and people going back to MR25

[MWB]

So you got a pm back saying that mrandall isn't town, and instead of holding onto that info to determine if he's red or green, you went for a kill? Seems odd.
I don't really by mrandall's claim either though.

this is why nan's opinion to let him live isnt a terrible idea. if there is a vig, which there has been for most games, randall will die tonight. i just wanted it to be known that he is not town. the pm did NOT list him as red, though. if for some reason there isnt a vig or doesnt have the ability to kill tonight, then here we are tomorrow with doubts about my role because of this.

im just thinking out loud.

to clarify, there was no colorization to mrandall. also, there was no colorization to my pm as well, so im assuming PB just isnt using them and mrandall is RED.

If he was posting from his phone he probably didn't color it because of that. However, I'm guessing he would have said he was RED (is this a new thing that EPP started) in the pm instead of just, "not town."

[MRandall25]

I may have stretched the truth :pop:

I'm the SK. no clue if there is a vigilante.

I have no affiliation. If I could, I'd like to stay alive and potentially help the town wun., with you guys killing me off at the end.

Only claimed vigilante BC it was closest role.

[PensHckyFan79]

I would like to hear form MRandall25 to see if he has better details about his role claim. It would suck to kill a green rp and have another outed in the first day phase, I guess it would suck worse to let a red slip through our fingers.

[MWB]

kill mrandall

Well, that makes things easier.

[MRandall25]

I'm not red though. If there is no vig, I can help.

[Sam's Drunk Dog]

Well there goes my theory. I thought perhaps PB was not considering green rps to be town, but mrandall proved that wrong.

[Sam's Drunk Dog]

So mrandall, you can kill every other night?

[MWB]

I'm not red though. If there is no vig, I can help.

If there is an independent, I bet there is no vig, especially in a game this small. I don't trust independents, because who knows what it takes for you to win. Or you could just be a red and lying about it.

[canaan]

i say kill him...hes already lied. i dont think he would have the villages best interest at heart. if he is an independent, it will continue to be a topic until hes killed.

[MRandall25]

So mrandall, you can kill every other night?

BC I'm the Joker, I get one every night.

And MWB, I don't care about winning it.

[MRandall25]

i say kill him...hes already lied. i dont think he would have the villages best interest at heart. if he is an independent, it will continue to be a topic until hes killed.

What did you want me to say? Cmon.