BATTLESTAR GALACTICA WARZ Game Thread

[thehockeyguru]

Like I said earlier, I really think there are two schools of thought here. #1. Is there a Red in the 3-6 range on EPP? #2. Why did the vote swing to Canaan and could Red's have jumped on at the end to finish EPP?

I think MWB and SDD are good candidates IMO. So I'll lynch MWB

I think this is a good approach. I'm leaning more toward columbia or SDD, though. MWB posted a "I'm very confused" after a perplexing exchange between columbia and WK. I agreed with MWB, so I guess I lean toward him being good.

That's what caught my eye. I dont know the history behind the exchange, but MWB is usually pretty sharp.

[redwill]

That's what caught my eye. I dont know the history behind the exchange, but MWB is usually pretty sharp.

I'm too lazy to quote it, but the exchange was very weird.

I'm going to

lynch columbia

Also, if columbia is bad, I wouldn't put it past WK to pull a page out of Pavel's playbook and put an early vote on a fellow red.

Just some thoughts.

[redwill]

I don't know any of the lore here, but let's just assume that shad is a baddie through and through and not a traitor cylon (as is implied).

Why would reds kill their own?

Excuse me?
Where did I say that I thought canaan was red?

canaan killed shad

I'm very confused.

This is what I was talking about.

[columbia]

So am I...not sure what I was talking about there.
Then again, I have no idea what MWB was asking.

[MRandall25]

That was an odd post by Columbia to start that exchange...

[MRandall25]

So am I...not sure what I was talking about there.
Then again, I have no idea what MWB was asking.

You said to assume Shad was still red. MWB asked why the reds would waste a night kill on another red.

It wasn't that hard to understand.

[columbia]

His question still doesn't make any sense.....the vig could have killed shad.
Why assume that the reds did?

[canaan]

I suspect Shad's cylon would be the only Colonial allied one in the game, if we're dealing early on before the final five reveal.

just caught up...was there a resolution/clarification on this? i might have missed it.

[newarenanow]

lynch rel

[MRandall25]

His question still doesn't make any sense.....the vig could have killed shad.
Why assume that the reds did?

Then why weren't there 2 kills?

And in any regard, that was a red move through and through. Why would the reds NOT attempt to kill Shad early? He's arguably the best player. Much easier game for the reds to get rid of Shad early (as they have practically every other game he hasn't been red for).

[columbia]

His question still doesn't make any sense.....the vig could have killed shad.
Why assume that the reds did?

Then why weren't there 2 kills?

And in any regard, that was a red move through and through. Why would the reds NOT attempt to kill Shad early? He's arguably the best player. Much easier game for the reds to get rid of Shad early (as they have practically every other game he hasn't been red for).

You're assuming that the reds have kills every night?
We don't know that.

[columbia]

He's arguably the best player.

I just saw that.

That's a bit of a stretch.

[MRandall25]

I'd say it's a pretty safe assumption, and your actions are speaking pretty loudly right now.

[MRandall25]

He's arguably the best player.

I just saw that.

That's a bit of a stretch.

Then why do the reds off him early every game?

[canaan]

He's arguably the best player.

I just saw that.

That's a bit of a stretch.

Then why do the reds off him early every game?

i know when i did it, its because his aggression led me to believe he was an RP. :shouldershrug.jpg:

[columbia]

They usually leave you around.....what does that say about you?

[MRandall25]

No comment.

But your hostility is telling :pop:

[canaan]

lynch rel

columbia is being too aggro to be red.

[PensHckyFan79]

whats the current vote?

[Willie Kool]

I suspect Shad's cylon would be the only Colonial allied one in the game, if we're dealing early on before the final five reveal.

just caught up...was there a resolution/clarification on this? i might have missed it.

This is a BSG reference, not necessarily a game reference. Wiki it for a full explanation.

[MRandall25]

lynch rel

columbia is being too aggro to be red.

I disagree. He's getting defensive the same way Factorial got defensive when someone called him out (but without the schizo voting habits).

[redwill]

I suspect Shad's cylon would be the only Colonial allied one in the game, if we're dealing early on before the final five reveal.

just caught up...was there a resolution/clarification on this? i might have missed it.

This is a BSG reference, not necessarily a game reference. Wiki it for a full explanation.

Ah. Makes some sense now. I'm familiar with the original and have never seen even a minute of the new one.

[Kaizer]

2 - pecky - columbia, MWB
4 - relantel - Slappy, SDD, nan, canaan
2 - columbia - WK, redwill
1 - THG -crank
1 - MWB - THG

8 to kill. deadline is 4 pm. if no limit is reached, all names with votes will go to the randomizer, with their names in as many times as there are votes on them.

[MRandall25]

In that case, I'm going to

Yellow Columbia.

For reasons I have previously stated.

[canaan]

weird...i randomized the list based on the parameters kaizer set and it returned EPP. hmph.