BATTLESTAR GALACTICA WARZ Game Thread

[Crankshaft]

1. SDD - EPP
2. MRandall - EPP
3. relantel - NO VOTE
4. MWB - EPP
5. canaan - EPP
7. pecky - canaan
8. shaf will return night 5 - NO VOTE
9. redwill - EPP
10. Willie Kool - canaan
11. CBear - NO VOTE
12. Slappy - EPP
13. nan - EPP
15. columbia - EPP
16. thehockeyguru - NO VOTE
17. crankshaft - EPP

One of those non-voters could be bad - trying to stay under the radar on the first day.

[Willie Kool]

1. SDD - EPP
2. MRandall - EPP
3. relantel - NO VOTE
4. MWB - EPP
5. canaan - EPP
7. pecky - canaan
8. shaf will return night 5 - NO VOTE
9. redwill - EPP
10. Willie Kool - canaan
11. CBear - NO VOTE
12. Slappy - EPP
13. nan - EPP
15. columbia - EPP
16. thehockeyguru - NO VOTE
17. crankshaft - EPP

One of those non-voters could be bad - trying to stay under the radar on the first day.

Shaf is blue. it was supposed to be a simple reveal.

[Crankshaft]

That leaves rel, cbear and thehockeyguru.

[MRandall25]

Not voting is a very typical rel move.

[Crankshaft]

thehockeyguru has had multiple posts today in other forums but hasn't posted in here yet.

[slappybrown]

Kill rel color please

I've seen him do the no participation thing while red probably 4 or 5 times. It's the best value on day 2 IMO. While he's likely blue according to the odds, it at least clears this issue up and we aren't debating it 4 phases from now when he still has no vote history

[Sam's Drunk Dog]

Yellow rel for reasons slappy mentioned.

Color me

[columbia]

Kill rel color please

[columbia]

Yellow rel for reasons slappy mentioned.

Color me

[MWB]

Kill rel color please

I've seen him do the no participation thing while red probably 4 or 5 times. It's the best value on day 2 IMO. While he's likely blue according to the odds, it at least clears this issue up and we aren't debating it 4 phases from now when he still has no vote history

He does the same thing when he's blue, and then comes back to help. I think it's too early to get rid of him, and isn't a bad red move to get him voted out like this.

[redwill]

I suspect Shad's cylon would be the only Colonial allied one in the game, if we're dealing early on before the final five reveal.

I'd still like to know what relantel meant by this. I have no idea what the words mean when put together like that.

[Kaizer]

2 - pecky - columbia, MWB
2 - relantel - Slappy, SDD
1 - columbia - WK

[slappybrown]

Kill rel color please

I've seen him do the no participation thing while red probably 4 or 5 times. It's the best value on day 2 IMO. While he's likely blue according to the odds, it at least clears this issue up and we aren't debating it 4 phases from now when he still has no vote history

He does the same thing when he's blue, and then comes back to help. I think it's too early to get rid of him, and isn't a bad red move to get him voted out like this.

I don't think there is any other vote that I see that is a higher value vote on day 2.

1. I never can get a read on him because of participation issues.
2. He does this when he is red.
3. He does this when he is blue.

Equals

No one has any idea what he's doing in the game, which is a net negative for the village.

If you have a better idea, I am all ears.

[Crankshaft]

I can buy into slappybrown's reasoning.

lynch relentel

[thehockeyguru]

Why are we going away from the EPP vote? It seems likely that a Red could have piled on especially after the Canaan train started moving a bit. What we also dont know is why did the vote split like it did?

[Crankshaft]

Why are we going away from the EPP vote? It seems likely that a Red could have piled on especially after the Canaan train started moving a bit. What we also dont know is why did the vote split like it did?

I find it kind of suspicious you show up only after your name was brought up. And you just jumped right into the fray instead of explaining your complete absence during the first day of voting.

[MRandall25]

I suspect Shad's cylon would be the only Colonial allied one in the game, if we're dealing early on before the final five reveal.

I'd still like to know what relantel meant by this. I have no idea what the words mean when put together like that.

Is it in any way related to the actual BSG stuff?

If so, then I may need it explained.

[PensHckyFan79]

Anyone got a clue what is going on with CBear3. In the handful of games I have played he is usually pretty active.

@Crankshaft: THG did just jump right in there a few other players mentioned he is usually late to the party so I dont know. This is only my 4/5th game so far so I'm relatively new as well.

[Crankshaft]

Anyone got a clue what is going on with CBear3. In the handful of games I have played he is usually pretty active.

@Crankshaft: THG did just jump right in there a few other players mentioned he is usually late to the party so I dont know. This is only my 4/5th game so far so I'm relatively new as well.

You really jumped to his defense rather quickly. Why is that?

[Crankshaft]

I may be reading too much into it, but I think both Penshckyfan79 and thehockeyguru are bad. I'm changing my vote accordingly.

save relentel; lynch thehockeyguru

If thehockeyguru shows up bad, Penshckyfan is my vote for the next day.

[MRandall25]

Anyone got a clue what is going on with CBear3. In the handful of games I have played he is usually pretty active.

Nah, this is pretty normal as far as CBear is concerned. He posted earlier, even though he didn't vote.

He is typically pretty helpful for the village. Can't recall a game where he's been one of the reds

[PensHckyFan79]

Just because he hasn't been one of the reds before has no impact on if he is red this game. But you answered my question I was trying to see if this was normal behavior for him.

[thehockeyguru]

Like I said earlier, I really think there are two schools of thought here. #1. Is there a Red in the 3-6 range on EPP? #2. Why did the vote swing to Canaan and could Red's have jumped on at the end to finish EPP?

I think MWB and SDD are good candidates IMO. So I'll lynch MWB

[MRandall25]

Just because he hasn't been one of the reds before has no impact on if he is red this game. But you answered my question I was trying to see if this was normal behavior for him.

That's also true, but I was saying that as more of a "Just because he's quiet at points doesn't mean he's a detriment to the village".

[redwill]

Like I said earlier, I really think there are two schools of thought here. #1. Is there a Red in the 3-6 range on EPP? #2. Why did the vote swing to Canaan and could Red's have jumped on at the end to finish EPP?

I think MWB and SDD are good candidates IMO. So I'll lynch MWB

I think this is a good approach. I'm leaning more toward columbia or SDD, though. MWB posted a "I'm very confused" after a perplexing exchange between columbia and WK. I agreed with MWB, so I guess I lean toward him being good.